The BeezerMN ReviewThe Beezer Review
Welcome Guest!
09-03-2010
Login | Register

Review Types

a Reviews By Author
a Reviews By Publisher
a Reviews By Date
a Reviews By Rating
Amazon.com
 
Online Eberron
 
 
 

 

2007-07-05
Shadowstorm
- Paul S. Kemp
Rating:
5/5
- Wizards of the Coast
 
 
ShadowstormShadowstorm by Paul S. Kemp is the second book in the Twilight War Trilogy. The first book is titled Shadowbred. Both of these book feature familiar characters from Mr. Kemp’s Erevis Cale trilogy. Fans on Mr. Kemp’s work will most assuredly find Shadowstorm to be of the high caliber of writing that we have come to expect from him.

Being that Shadowstorm is the bridge novel of this trilogy, I had mixed hopes on just what to expect from it. It seems all too common now-a-days that bridge novels in trilogies do little to further the story. Some seem to be just filler until the next book. That is not the case with this book. This book has many elements most fantasy fans will enjoy; large scale battles, magic use, political intrigue, and a great deal of character development.

The plot of this novel continues right where Shadowbred left off. As with the first book in this trilogy, the plot of this book is actually several sub-plots interwoven to create the complete story. Upon completion of this book, it is rather evident that the final book in this trilogy, Shadowrealm, will be a stunning climax as all the events of the first two books collide. Some of the sub-plots that readers can expect to read about are; Cale’s promise to his god and how he attempts to fulfill that promise, Mag’s dealing with events that seem to spiral out of control for him, the Overmistress’s quest to lay siege to Selgaunt, the Nightseer’s yet to be revealed plot, the Hulorn’s further development, and more. If that list seems like a lot, it is. Mr. Kemp successfully crams as much as he possibly can into the pages of this novel. Mr. Kemp also succeeds in inviting the reader to make assumptions about what will happen later in the book, only to wrench those assumptions away in very memorable scenes.

As with past Kemp novels, that characters in this book are second to none. Mr. Kemp has clearly proven time and time again his ability to make each and every character in his books special. Mr. Kemp balances his characters well, there are characters that readers will love, there are characters that readers will hate, but there are also characters that are in the middle of the spectrum as well – some will like them and others will hate them. Yet, each character elicits a response. There is also a great deal of character development for multiple characters in this novel. The characters that seem to really develop the most are; Mags, Cale, Rivalen, Tamlin, Abelar, and Elyril. Much like the plot, if that list seems large, it is. However, at no point in the story does anything suffer because of the multiple plot points or the multiple characters. Quite contrary, in that the book seems to move along at a fast pace because of all the various things going on. Mr. Kemp does a fantastic job of giving us just enough information to advance the story (and characters, but not so much where the reader knows everything, or becomes bored with a character.

The pace of this book makes the reader feel like they are running a marathon at sprint speed. I do not mean that in a negative way though. The pacing is fantastic and challenges the reader to put the book aside, even for a little bit. Mr. Kemp’s prose also lends itself to easy reading. There are no parts of this novel that get bogged down due to explanations or excessive dialog. Every word in this novel is chosen for a reason and clearly conveys the vision Mr. Kemp had for this particular book.

In my review of Shadowbred, I commented on how there are first person scenes that took away from the book for me. I realize this is purely a self-bias , as I have never been able to read first person stories. The first person scenes are again present in this book, however, they are not as ‘disruptive’ as they were (for me) in the first book. They are more subdued and to the point. I am assuming that the third novel will also have first person scenes, but if they are like the ones in this book I won’t have a problem with it. It does add more depth to the character and allows the reader to see more ‘inside’ of Mags and what he is thinking.

The one criticism I have of this book is, at times, it felt like a couple of the characters were becoming too powerful for the scope of the story. This mostly applied to Cale and Rivalen. There are a couple scenes in particular that Cale and Rivalen dominated and I had no doubt they were going to come out of it unscathed, when I think it would have been better served to give a little sense of vulnerability. There was one scene in particular where I felt like it was just ‘showing off’ of different powers and new ways to kill people.

Other than that, I felt this was a fantastic novel. It is grittier and darker than most Forgotten Realms books on the market today. There are at least three scenes that I was surprised to read just based on the graphic nature of them. Don’t get me wrong, they fit superbly with the story, but they also certainly pushed the envelope of the PG-13 rating that Wizards of the Coast strives for.

As with every other Kemp book I have read, I would not hesitate to recommend this book to fantasy fans. While 2007 is only half over, this novel may well end up on my top 5 books of the year list.

 
- BeezerMN
Buy it now

To leave a comment, you must first login or register.

 

2009-01-16
gerald
First things first. While "Shadowbred" bored me, this novel, the bridge of the trilogy, surely found its way to stick to my hands that I found it hard to put down even for a few minutes. More details were presented about the most significant characters - Cale, Rivalen, Riven, Mags, Elyril. Since it's the characters that primarily drive any novel, determine whether it is worth my time or not, I will focus on the characters of this novel. I am still not used to the new sort of "good guy" attitude that Riven radiated, but it's not that disturbing. His true self, his behavior, as seen in the the previous Kemp novels, remained intact. The first person point of view still bothered me as it did in Shadowbred. Seriously, Kemp could have still pulled out Mags's sufferings even using the third person POV, and perhaps more effectively. With Cale, well, nothing much new. He's still as selfless as ever when it comes to his friends. I am surprised though as to how he suddenly became powerful. Elyril's presence in the novel was still as boring as it was in the first. Though I clearly understand her purpose and the purpose behind that purpose, I just don't see why she didn't do anything to avenge for what Rivalen did to her. True, they served the same goddess, but could she have just asked for any signs if it was okay for her to avenge her fate? RIVALEN. Now, I would have to write a lot about this guy! First, I must admit I am biased. I love the archwizards of Netheril. That's not only because they are the most powerful wizards in Faerun - though that's a big factor - but also because they present a somewhat ambigious image of good and evil; as if their actions show that a pinch or a ton of good could come from evil, depending on where you see the point... Well, since the Netheril Trilogy, I have been watching their every significant moves. And I should say that one primal reason I chose to read Twilight War Trilogy is the reappearance of the Archwizards of Shade, who had already made their devastating presence in The Return of the Archwizards Trilogy. Okay, back to Rivalen. I am glad that Kemp has been consistent with Rivalen's actions, which were all driven by his two motives/genuine goals that - I believe - will clash in the third book. His fight with a creature (I just would not state exactly what so as not to spoil anyone) left me breathless. It was clear that no archwizard, especially a Prince of Shade, should be trifled with. However, I don't see why neither he nor Cale left their hand-to-hand, sword-to-sword battle unscathed. A little vulnerability would have been good. Besides, Prince Rivalen is two thousand years old plus and an archwizard. I think Kemp should have made that point clearer - Cale's and Rivalen's difference in age and power - by giving Rivalen a clear win thru spellcraft ---at least in this first fight. Though they presented some boring chain of actions, the characters still manage to emerge as interesting a possible. 3 stars for Kemp!

 

 

   
     

Site designed & Coded by Laethyn

Copyright 2007©